Skip to main content
News
Mortgage Rates

Ex-Renters Face Higher Mortgage Payments in September

First-time buyers in September faced higher mortgage payments, with 56% paying more than their previous rent, highlighting a shift in the housing market.

By David Sampson
19 October 2026
3 min read
UK mortgage rates article image for Ex-Renters Face Higher Mortgage Payments in September

TL;DR

  • •56% of first-time buyers in September paid an average of £39 more on their mortgage than their previous rent.
  • •This marks a significant increase from last year, affecting many older buyers who opted for larger homes.

Written by David Sampson for Mortgage118. Last updated 19 October 2026. Reviewed against our . Mortgage118 is a directory — not FCA-authorised and not a mortgage adviser.

Recent analysis reveals that many first-time buyers who transitioned from renting to homeownership in September are now facing higher monthly mortgage payments. This trend underscores the growing financial strain on new homeowners, particularly as mortgage rates continue to rise.

Why Are First-Time Buyers Paying More?

According to research by Hamptons, 56% of first-time buyers who purchased homes in September reported paying approximately 8.6% more on their monthly mortgage compared to their previous rent. This is a notable increase from just a year ago, when only a third of first-time buyers experienced higher mortgage payments than their rent. The average monthly mortgage payment for these buyers reached £1,277, indicating a shift in the financial market for new homeowners.

How Does Age Impact Mortgage Costs?

The analysis highlighted that older first-time buyers, particularly those in their 40s, are more likely to incur higher monthly housing costs. A striking 67% of this demographic reported mortgage payments exceeding their previous rent. This trend can be attributed to their preference for larger homes to accommodate their needs, leading to higher loan amounts and shorter mortgage terms, averaging 27 years compared to 31 years for buyers in their 30s and 34 years for those in their 20s.

What Are the Implications for Renters?

As rental growth continues to rise, the implications for renters are significant. In September, newly agreed rents in Great Britain increased by 2.7% annually, marking the fastest growth rate since November 2024. The average rent now stands at £1,433, up from £1,396 last year. This persistent rental increase may push more tenants to consider homeownership, despite the higher mortgage costs they might face. However, existing tenants saw an average rent increase of 5.6%, indicating that the rental market remains competitive.

What This Means for Homebuyers and Investors

For potential homebuyers, particularly those transitioning from renting, the current market conditions present a challenging scenario. With over half of first-time buyers facing higher mortgage payments, the financial justification for purchasing a home has become less straightforward compared to previous years. Investors should also take note of the rising rental prices, as this may indicate a robust demand for rental properties, but they must balance this with the increasing costs of homeownership.

FAQs

Are first-time buyers still finding it affordable to buy a home?

While many first-time buyers are facing higher mortgage payments than their previous rent, the decision to buy a home often depends on personal financial circumstances and long-term investment goals.

What trends are affecting the rental market currently?

The rental market is experiencing consistent growth, with annual rent increases and competitive demand, particularly in regions like the South East and South West.

About David Sampson

David Sampson writes about the UK mortgage market for Mortgage118, covering specialist lending, market trends, and practical advice for borrowers. All content is reviewed for accuracy against FCA guidelines and current market data.